Archive | Mobile RSS feed for this section

A Pending Spectrum War?

There might be a pending spectrum war, warned Jim Burger of Washington law firm Dow Lohnes.
At the HPA Tech Retreat, he reported that the wireless industry has urged the FCC to identify 800MHz of spectrum for mobile broadcasting.
Where will it come from?, Burger asked, pointing out that terrestrial broadcasting just transitioned to DTV.
He reported that the Stimulus Bill requires the FCC to submit a “National Broadband Plan” to Congress in March.
Getting chuckles from the HPA audience, he added that an FCC spokesperson said spectrum reallocation would be “voluntary.”

Mobile TV On The Way

“It is right in front of us,” Paul Childers, Rubber Duck Media Lab, said of Mobile TV during a panel at the HPA Tech Retreat.

According to industry journalist Debra Kaufman, who moderated, predictions suggest that 63 million smartphones will be in use in the U.S. by 2013, and mobile TV subscriptions are expected to reach an estimated 23 million in 2010.

ATSC’s Jerry Whitaker presented an overview of ATSC Mobile DTV, a broadcast spectrum that affords delivery of realtime and non-realtime TV content and data to mobile and handheld devices.

Tools include channel listings, an electronic service guide and subscriber interaction (security, billing enabled services), a rich media environment and viewer data collection.

ATSC is now studying a scalable full-channel option. The goals include increasing user options, backward and forward compatibility, and no impact on legacy services.

As an example of bandwidth allocation, he suggested that of the 19.4 Mbps used by broadcasters, HD might use 13-15 Mbps, an additional SD multicast might use 2-4 Mbps, PSIP might use 0.3 Mbps and two to three mobile service might use 4-6 Mbps.

ATSC is launching a Mobile DTV consumer showcase in Washington to help accelerate the commercialization of the services.

Naturally, the topic shifted to 3D.

“Mobile 3D will become increasingly important, especially because the mobile turnover is faster than TVs,” said Ethan Schur, chief marketing officer at TDVision.

He reported that there are already different types of autostereo options for mobile devices. He commented: “Personally, I don’t think autostereo (for TVs) will be ready in 20 years. For a mobile devices, I think it can be viable.”

He urged the extension of the ATSC Mobile DTV standard to include 3D.

entourage-edge-dualbook-concept-revealed-0

Parting Thoughts: General Observations

As we leave Las Vegas and tie a bow around CES 2010, here are some general observations from the ETC reporting team:

The show had a super-dynamic feel. Last year, people were depressed and the event felt a bit empty.  This year – despite speculation that the confab would suffer from lack of big announcements and the effects of a limping economy – the high level of energy surprised us.  The show was slammed and there was a LOT of optimism in the air… and it was infectious.

As predicted, 3D was everywhere. It was perhaps even a bit more everywhere than people imagined.  Last year’s backroom demos were this year’s front-of-booth highlights.  DirecTV live 3D feeds and actual 3D Blu-ray discs playing on actual Full-HD 3D displays were in almost every major CE booth.  There was also a lot of live 2D-3D conversion around – maybe disruptive or perhaps just a nice parlor trick for 3DTV buyers to show their friends.

Over-the-top Internet-connected devices were everywhere, too. Last year, we saw ethernet jacks in a few TVs from the CE companies and widgets, etc. on some Blu-ray players.  This year, it’s gone mainstream.  The majority of the sets from the major manufacturers have ethernet, EVERYTHING is connected, Skype is now available in HD for HDTVs and PCs, and even Vizio has a strong play with its huge line-up of affordable, easy-to-use, wireless networked TVs.

All of that said, there was no “Pet Rock” at the show – the single must-have gadget. The Best in Show award from CNET’s Best of CES awards went to Panasonic for its VT25 series of 3D-capable HDTVs…and NetShelter’s Last Gadget Standing top winner was the Boxee Box from D-Link that helps you share Internet content with your HDTV.  But as Google and Apple had hoped for, everyone was talking about the Google Nexus One smartphone and the rumored-to-be-coming-later-this-month Apple Tablet, both of which were not at the show.

Tablet PCs, netbooks and e-readers with a wide variety of screen sizes and functionality took on a surprise presence at the show. We were particularly impressed with the enTourage eDGe, the first dualbook e-reader.  This cool device flips open to two screens: the first is an LCD screen with the functionality of a tablet notebook and the second is an e-paper screen for reading, highlighting and annotating documents.  We’ve just scratched the surface of possibilities with these affordable and increasingly popular devices (just think about the Kindle…).

Before we sign off, we’ve included a part 2 to our parting thoughts, a brief list of things to watch for in 2010.  Be sure to check it out.

And it seems only fitting that we include one final video.  Carolyn Giardina, one of our roving show floor reporters, wraps up her video coverage of CES by providing a brief overview of this year’s trends – from 3D everywhere to over-the-top tablet PCs to emerging technologies such as 4G networks.

This movie requires Adobe Flash for playback.

Thanks for reading the blog for this year’s CES 2010.  A special thank-you to ETC’s sponsors who make our work possible.  We’re Leaving Las Vegas…

KC Blake, Sarah Blake, Carlos Crooks, George Gerba, Carolyn Giardina, Bryan Gonzalez, Frank Irving, Leander Kung, Phil Lelyveld, Edie Meadows, Paula Parisi, Mark Schroeder, Rob Scott, William Sheng, David Wertheimer, Joyce Yi

And our sponsor-contributors/tipsters:

Wendy Aylsworth, Bryan Ellenburg, Bob Kisor, Bob Lambert, Theron Trowbridge

Read the team’s thoughts on trends to watch in 2010

CES_booth

Parting Thoughts: Trends to Watch for in 2010

As we hightail it out of Vegas with the desert dust settling behind us, the ETC reporting team would like to recommend a few things worth keeping your eyes open for in the upcoming year, based on our observations of CES 2010:

A revitalized industry-wide commitment to 3D. Fresh on the heels of theatrical successes (congratulations, Jim Cameron…) and the gradual adoption of other 3D screenings involving sports, stage performances, live music, etc. – the CE industry and content providers are tackling 3D for the home with renewed vigor:

– Watch for a slew of new 3D devices promised by nearly every major CE manufacturer, including (but certainly not limited to) 3D HDTVs, 3D Blu-ray players, and 3D-capable gaming systems.

– We’re looking forward to the first wave of 3D Blu-ray titles, especially “Disney’s A Christmas Carol,” Sony Pictures Animation’s “Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs” and DreamWorks’ “Monsters vs. Aliens.”

– Attendees at this year’s show were excited to hear announcements of planned 3D broadcasts and new 3D cable channels.  Watch for ESPN3D to begin airing in June… and watch for the first 24/7 exclusively 3D channel to debut from Discovery, Sony and IMAX.  Also, look for DirecTV live 3D like we saw on the show floor at Panasonic, LG and Samsung.

– In addition to the ongoing efforts we’ll be coordinating at ETC, we were thrilled to hear about new 3D testing facility commitments from the likes of CableLabs in Colorado and Testronic Labs in Burbank.  Additionally, CBS is expanding its Television City consumer research facility located at the MGM Grand in Las Vegas.  CBS and Nielsen are partnering to add 3,000 square feet onto the existing facility, and Sony has promised to provide the initial 3D equipment.  We should also mention that the MPEG Industry Forum has created a new 3DTV Working Group, that held its first meeting during CES.

Touch screens, netbooks and tablet PCs were rampant at this year’s show, with speculation and promise of a slew of new products in development. Not surprising, it seems that portability, cost, functionality and connectivity are at the forefront.  And with an increasing demographic growing reliant on the touch screens so popular with iPhones and similar devices, we should expect to see an impact on nearly all CE products.

Will time prove that Google and Apple were wise not to debut the Nexus One and Apple Tablet (whatever it will be called) at CES? Google’s new Android smartphone marks the company’s first foray into hardware and could wind up protecting the company’s dominance in online advertising.  But will its self-proclaimed “superphone” with speech recognition take on Apple’s iPhone over time and help expand Google’s reach from the PC to the mobile world?  And what impact will the Apple Tablet have, if any, on the array of tablet PCs showcased at CES?  We’ll be watching this race carefully this year.

Over-the-top connected services will take on a new dynamic. When this theme emerged at last year’s show it was little more than a conversation, but by CES 2010 things had really taken flight with Net-connected TVs and widgets from the likes of Vizio and LG, among others.  By next year’s CES, we expect it will be difficult to find a TV or device that doesn’t connect to the Internet via ethernet or wireless.  And the number and types of over-the-top products and services that begin to crop up in 2010 should be really interesting to watch.

Gestural interfaces still had a presence at this year’s show and may integrate with a new direction in CE devices. Last year, we saw the first gestural interfaces from pioneering companies such as PrimeSense.  During 2009, we saw Microsoft announce and demo to universal acclaim “Project Natal”, based on PrimeSense’s chipset.  And if the Wii has revolutionized and democratized games by providing two points of information (from the IR controllers), gestural interfaces potentially bring millions of points of information into the equation without asking people to have a remote control.  Watch this trend… It’s going to be big.

Keep thinking about LTE and 4G. Even though they didn’t have an enormous presence at the show, these are technologies that should start to play out in the next 12 months.  For example, ZyXEL showed its fixed LTE router for the home.  The router will enable operators to offer high-speed Internet service to the home via cellular networks with data rates up to 50Mbps throughput.  There were several other LTE/4G products on the floor including products from LG and Samsung.  In addition, Sprint, Verizon and AT&T have all announced network upgrades to support these systems.  This is a big trend to watch for 2010 and you can bet that next year at the show LTE/4G will be a hot topic.

Better Organization, Search and Discovery. The myriad over-the-top services cropping up at the show this year creates a double-edged sword for consumers.  So many ways to get content (now on your TV), so few ways to easily find it.  The explosion of over-the-top and new access-enabling options (e.g. DECE and KeyChest) will highlight a void and an opportunity for companies to make super-simple search, discovery, and access to all your digital content.  This should begin to be a major theme in 2010.

And finally, keep a close watch on multifunction AV data cabling. Probably not the sexiest theme at the show, but one that will be paramount to a new generation of connected devices.  Intel garnered a lot of attention when it touted its Light Peak high-speed optical cable technology that can achieve data rates of 10GB per second.  And if you thought HDMI made connections simpler, wait until you see HDBaseT… The demo we saw from an Israeli company called Valens was of a single Cat-5 ethernet cable carrying power, uncompressed 1080p video, ethernet, and control data.  Very impressive.

We’re sure there will be a few surprises in store for us in 2010, but these are the technologies and trends this year’s show has us excited about as we start the new year.

Thanks for reading the blog for this year’s CES 2010.  A special thank-you to ETC’s sponsors who make our work possible.  We’re Leaving Las Vegas…

KC Blake, Sarah Blake, Carlos Crooks, George Gerba, Carolyn Giardina, Bryan Gonzalez, Frank Irving, Leander Kung, Phil Lelyveld, Edie Meadows, Paula Parisi, Mark Schroeder, Rob Scott, William Sheng, David Wertheimer, Joyce Yi

And our sponsor-contributors/tipsters:

Wendy Aylsworth, Bryan Ellenburg, Bob Kisor, Bob Lambert, Theron Trowbridge

Universal_Remote_edit2

Silvers Summit: CE Products for Advanced Generations

What you should know about ‘Gear for Geezers’…

If you think focusing on seniors means making phones with oversized keypads and “I’ve-fallen-and-I-can’t-get-up” alarms, think again.

The exhibitors at CES’s Silvers Summit spoke with us about advice for the entertainment industry, based on their experience designing and marketing products for an aging population.

“They are the best customers in the world, but nobody has figured out how to do it right for them,” said Aaron Pollack of cell phone provider Jitterbug.

Boomers pay bills on time, give conscientious customer feedback, and are extremely loyal (witness Jitterbug’s churn rate of 1.5%).  While they may be beginning to have issues with hearing, vision, and manual dexterity, they also have the interest, the income, and the time to enjoy great technology and entertainment.

Some advice from the pros for reaching this valuable demographic:

Stick With Sexy Design
Just because they’re aging doesn’t mean they’re square, exhibitors said. Reaching the key baby boomer demographic means creating products that don’t make them feel like they’re getting old.

“My number one advice is to make it sexy.  In their minds, they’re young and cool, and they’re not ready for the old folks home,” said Curt Stone of the Quality of Life Foundry at Carnegie Mellon University.  “You don’t have to dumb it down for them.  Make tech that is universally appealing but also adaptive to special needs, and you’ll have a winner.”

Simplify, Simplify
While the CES floor is crowded with complicated devices and expanding choices, this population wants it simpler and streamlined.  They’re overwhelmed and turned off by remote controls or set-top boxes with too many or unclearly-labeled buttons.

Swedish company Doro has taken it to the ultimate extreme, with a six-button universal remote control (on/off, volume up/down, and channel up/down) that won’t overwhelm anybody.  That may be going farther than most of the 55+ crowd needs, but the key feature of all exhibitors in Silvers Summit was that they cut out extraneous content and features, rather than adding more.

Focus on Making & Strengthening Connections
This population uses their tech to stay in touch with people they care about, exhibitors said.  Companies that support those goals will succeed.

“People stay connected by watching TV together or talking on the phone, and when they lose their hearing and stop sharing those things with their families their connections unravel,” said Michelle Maher of ClearSounds.  “Use technology to appeal to the emotional side of those family connections, and you’ll reach this group.”

Provide “High-touch” Customer Service
That means no labyrinthine automated telephone directories, no overseas customer service, and extremely patient and flexible reps.

“The relationship that develops is more like a family relationship,” said Chuck Lalonde of MyGait, which offers computer systems for elderly customers with custom hardware, software, and support.  He said people call or email with questions like, “How do I find a good Chinese restaurant in Vegas?” and their reps just roll with it, emailing back links to a Google map with directions.

“It definitely costs more to run a call center out of America than India,” said Pollack of Jitterbug.  “But it is absolutely what these customers want.”

Think Differently About Billing & Privacy
As mobile entertainment takes off, mobile purchasing and billing issues will become more complicated, and many aging customers simply aren’t comfortable with paying for things on the fly.  Reaching them may require some creativity and a range of payment options.

Jitterbug found that many users were afraid of contracts and worried about sharing social security, credit card, or bank account numbers over the phone or the Internet.  So they let them pay the old-fashioned way, month-to-month and through the mail.

“We mail them a bill and they pay on time,” said Pollack.  “We have far fewer problems than you might expect.”  Jitterbug also offers automatic online billing for those who are interested.

Ballmer_HP_slate

Microsoft’s Ballmer touts new Slate PCs

Slate PCs had a rather sizzly presence at CES, though most of them were either shown in prototype or not shown at all (as with Apple’s anticipated tablet or the Microsoft’s upcoming dual-screen Courier device).

Microsoft’s Steve Ballmer highlighted a number of Windows 7-powered “slates,” which seem to be aiming for the sweet spot between iPhone and a computer – a larger, more video-friendly screen than an iPhone with the computing power of a netbook.  In terms of portability, the slates fall somewhere between the two, which means they could also serve as ebook readers.  Though they’re much heavier than the fleet of ultra-lightweight e-readers on display at CES, they can run Kindle, Blio and Adobe e-reader software.

During his keynote address Ballmer gave a nice plug to the Blio eReader software developed by Ray Kurzweil that runs on Windows 7.  Blio allows you to do things like take notes and delve several layers into a book, drilling down into illustrations and charts.  It also offers text-to-speech, turning your ebook into an audio book.

Ballmer showcased slate units from HP, Archos and Pegatron, though not the Courier (which Microsoft will reportedly manufacture itself, expanding its position in the hardware space beyond Xbox and Zune).

The HP slate was the smallest of the three and described as “perfect for reading, surfing the Web and taking entertainment on-the-go.” The 8.5×11-inch screen unit from Taiwanese manufacturer Pegatron was the largest.

Dell, Lenovo and Fusion Garage also have slate PCs scheduled for release in 2010.

ATSC_MV

FLO TV: Wireless TV-to-Mobile System

[This post has been revised thanks to Debra Kaufman's comment below]

The Mobile Digital TV space has a few platform players (ATSC-MH, FLO, MobiTV, etc.), and a couple of the  competing formats had displays only a few hundred feet apart in the Central Hall.

FLO TV devices come in a variety of configurations, from in-dash to handheld.

[/caption]

FLO TV (owned by Qualcomm) has been up and running for about four years, offering a channel package not unlike that of basic cable, available over the air on the channel 55 frequency, which Qualcomm spent the past five years buying up in major markets. FLO TV itself has been on the air for about four years, providing mobile TV to select phones on the Verizon, VCast and AT&T platform.

At CES, FLO TV unveiled its own device, the FLO 350 (so named because the screen is a diagonal 3.5-inches).  The first generation FLO 350 has a bright screen and excellent audio, though there was a bit of motion blur to the native 320x240p image.

The Qualcomm-owned company is selling its mini-TV for $249 at Best Buy, Radio Shack and Amazon, which will include a six month subscription to the signal, which will thereafter be billed in the area of $19.95 per month for content including ESPN, Nickelodeon, Fox, Disney, ABC, NBC, CBS and many others.  Manufacturers like Audiovox and Advent offer in-dash FLO displays for the car.

If the crowd activity at the FLO TV display – part of the Wireless Mobility Brought to You By Qualcomm “Techzone” – is any indicator, interest in mobile digital is high.

Sprint4G

Sprint Into Overdrive: 4G Wi-Fi

Though 4G is a ubiquitous topic of discussion at CES – referenced in keynotes by Intel and Microsoft as well as the “what’s cool?” conversations, there’s precious little in terms of product to either showcase or help define the product here at the show.  Sprint, which is the first and thus far only cell carrier to offer 4G in the US – though for data, not talk – appears to be the only company to launch a new 4G device here, and it’s pretty nifty.

The Sprint Overdrive allows you to create your own personal Wi-Fi hotspot on-the-go.  The tiny box draws down the 4G signal and disperses it through five USB ports – essentially a mobile router.  And Sprint claims the 4G speeds are up to 10x faster than 3G.

It has 15MB of onboard storage.  It also has GPS capabilities tied to a Google Maps.  “It’s great if companies want to get a camera on one of their trucks.  They can put a camera on it and track the location,” a Sprint rep suggested.  The device has 16 MB of onboard storage, three hours of battery life and 36 hours of standby.

Though 4G is currently limited to fewer than 15 US markets, Sprint expects to be in just under 100 markets by the end of the year, when phones should begin to hit the market.  And the 4G gear falls back to 3G when the higher bandwidth isn’t available.

Trends in Mobile 03

ETC Panel: Trends in Mobile Entertainment

Keeping up with consumer’s insatiable demand for content is the key challenge facing the mobile entertainment industry, said panelists on ETC’s final Thursday afternoon presentation.

“There isn’t a technology that can handle the growth we’re seeing today,” said Glenn Lurie, president of emerging devices and resale at AT&T.  ”We spent $17.5 billion on our network this year, and just keeping up with it we’re going to run out of bandwidth.  We need help from the FCC, and we’re pressing on that.  This is a worldwide issue.”

AT&T’s network experienced 6700% growth in data usage in the last 13 quarters, Lurie said.  “There’s no way we’re going to keep up with the demand.  The only way is to look for other alternative solutions instead of all wireless.”

Mobile digital TV is one solution to the bandwidth shortage.

“The network that can bring something like the SuperBowl to every mobile device is the the broadcast network,” said Anne Schelle, president of the Open Mobile Video Coalition.  “What’s missing today is access to live content on mobile devices, and that’s what local broadcasters do.”

She said live local programming is also what people, including millenials, want.  According to OMVC research, people value both live and on-demand content equally, but separately, with news leading as the preferred live content.

Ken Plotkin, CEO of Hauppauge Digital, agreed that mobile digital TV delivers valuable content without jamming the wireless networks.  “The key thing is to preserve bandwidth with broadcast TV,” he said.  “The trend in the future is location-aware TV services broadcast, and broadcast TV preserves bandwidth for people want to have on-demand video on their wireless.”

Of course, business models to pay for mobile entertainment are still developing.

Lurie said subscription models for voice have been evolving for years, from individual to family plans, but the models have not been fully figured out for data plans.  “Three years ago, data was a business tool, but now it’s an everybody tool.  We’re going to continue to innovate around data price offerings.”

He added part of the challenge in the U.S. is the availability of unlimited plans.  “Very few foreign countries have unlimited plans,” he said.  “They all have tiered plans, where you pay this much and you can use this much. The second you have unlimited plans, you have a whole new set of problems.”

“We all want more content and we want it now,” said Dan Dodge, CEO of QNX Software Systems.  “There are two challenges with this: the business model and the back-end infrastructure.  We have to figure out the back-end billing solution and make it easy for the consumer.”

Interactive digital signage that connects users to an expert via video-conferencing or acts as a purchase portal may be in the future, too.

“There’s a really broad interest level in this kind of digital signage right now, but no one has the answer,” said Roger Sanford, VP of media services at Mediatile.  “This could change everything.”

Mitch Singer, president of Digital Entertainment Content Ecosystem and CTO at Sony Pictures Entertainment, said digital distribution will be most successful if it rolls out in a standardized process like the DVD.

“Imagine if you can standardize file format, multiple resolutions, and aggregate it in a single place regardless of how I bought it, and there’s an authentication service that knows who I am and what I’m entitled to, and then it magically appears in my Netflix queue,” he said.  “The moment we standardize that process, we’ve dramatically reduced costs on back-end infrastructure.”

Moderator Steve West of Alcatel Lucent asked the panel about connected cars, since in the US alone people spend an average of 500 million hours a week in cars.

“A car is the ultimate captive environment, but a challenge is that automakers have a cycle of innovation at odds with the current consumer,” said Dodge.  “People spend $50,000 on a car they’re going to own for 10 years and it has out-of-date technology… We’re looking for long-term solutions.  With your car, your media has to live in the cloud and you have to be able to buy it once and access it anywhere.”

Despite concerns about the dangers of distracted driving, Dodge sees some potential positive safety developments with connected cars.

“If your car slips a little on a wet road, that information should go into the car and out to the cloud and back down to the cars behind you, letting them know the road is a little slippery ahead,” he said.  “We talk about the connected car being a source of distraction, but maybe it’s a source of driver safety.  The network ties it all together.”

Looking forward, the panel predicted that tablets would take off, as the natural extension of the small smartphone screen.  However, “if you think the amount of info consumed now is a lot, wait until tablets go big,” said Plotkin.

Crowd_shot 01

ETC Panel: Connected TVs and Devices – The Changing Face of Digital Delivery

We’re just in the “first inning” of a new game of digital content delivery, said panelists on the ETC’s Thursday afternoon session on connected devices.  And 2010 will be a year of experimentation, surprises, and gathering data.

“By next year, connected TV will be something people expect,” said Russ Schafer, senior director of product marketing at Yahoo! Connected TV and Desktop.  “By early next year more manufacturers will promote connectivity as part of the experience, and that will drive innovation as expectations go up.”

“This year is about experimentation,” said Matt McRae, VP of products for Vizio.  “Next year we’ll have a lot more data about sales rates, price points that trigger mass adoption, and consumer preferences.  I think you’ll see about 20 million connected units deployed this year, and because they’re connected, the TV you buy in January will be different in December because of updates through the Internet.  For the first time we can layer services on top of content.  How that works will dictate what the second inning looks like.”

The executives from Channels.com, NBC Universal, Vizio, Warner Bros., and Yahoo! Connected TV each shared their thoughts on the challenges and opportunities of connected devices.

“To us, it’s more about personalization, additional services, and multi-screen activity than it is about ‘over-the-top’ services,” said JB Perrette, president of digital and alliance distribution and content distribution strategy at NBC Universal.  “There’s no reason it has to be competitive to cable or satellite, there’s no reason why players in that space can’t also be players in personalized, connected services delivered to devices across multiple screens and with services that don’t exist today.”

“This is not just new ways of delivery to the home, but the whole concept of the connected living room,” said Thomas Gewecke president of digital distribution for Warner Bros.  It’s a foundational change in the movie viewing experience, because now we can deliver services around the movie… so when you turn on the TV, your BD player connects, figures out who you are, and begins to inform your viewing experience.  We are spending a lot of time considering this.”

One of the exciting opportunities of connected TVs and devices is the richness of real-time data from the customer.

“A lot of the data we’ll gain in the next year will come straight from our consumers.  We’ll know what they like and what they don’t like, based on what they do and do not use,” said McRae.  “It’s pretty democratic.

Vizio has already gathered valuable consumer use information from their current batch of connected TV customers.

“Right now, over half of over-the-top use for TV is streaming video like Netflix and Hulu, which makes sense – that’s why you buy a TV, and it’s low-hanging fruit… Another 25% of use, which was a surprise, is actually music,” McRae said.  “A lot of people fire up Pandora and walk away and let it play.  The third most common use was interactivity, like Twitter or Facebook while watching sports or a media premiere.”

Panel moderator David Wertheimer asked about the need for standards.

From a manufacturer’s point of view, McRae said standards are crucial. “There are all these different contents, and they’re different on so many levels from DRM onward.  Making them all work is actually quite onerous,” he said.  “Lack of standards drives fragmentation and different rules.  We need to clean it up so we can focus on discovery and personalization.”

Perrette said simplicity is the key concept for connected TVs this year. “Simplicity in standards, in user experience, in UI, and especially simplicity of the message to the consumer,” he said, bringing up another key issue of consumer education.  “If we get too technical, instead of leading with the experience in a simple way, the adoption experience will be a lot flatter than if we keep it simple.”

Schafer said he would sum up the three key concepts as “Personalization, integration, and scalability.  How do you make integration right?  How do you make it scaleable so you can be flexible for the market you’re distributing in?”

The panel discussed the current state of set-top boxes.  Gewecke said he thinks game consoles are the current leading connected TV device.

“That may not be the case a few years from now, but companies that sell game devices are getting more sophisticated and using them as a means to sell other content and services. WB has seen significant growth in video game partners, and there is a very interesting crossover when you get the right environment between gamers and a video audience,” Gewecke said. “Games have been the vanguard and they will continue to be strong.”

Perrette said the consumer experience is still a challenge with most set-top boxes, but things will improve as navigation becomes more visual and simple.

Sean Doherty, CEO of Channels.com, said the new features like Wi-Fi on connected TVs will help these and other devices catch up with game consoles.  “These TVs have great potential, but there are some bumps in the road to be worked on.  However, I think you’ll see the progress and a greater variety of content on all kinds of connected devices,” he said.